Wood doesn't care how tightly you installed the screw. It's going to move anyway. Your job is to give it somewhere to go.
You found a beautiful piece of walnut. You jointed it, planed it, glued up a tabletop, sanded it perfectly, and built a base that could probably support a pickup truck. Then you screwed the top down tightly so it could never move. Unfortunately, the wood didn't get the memo. Here's one of the most important lessons in woodworking: Solid wood moves. Good furniture is designed to let it.
Why Does Wood Move?
Wood may have been cut from a tree years ago, kiln dried, milled into lumber, and turned into furniture, but it still responds to its environment. As humidity changes, wood absorbs and releases moisture. When its moisture content changes, its dimensions change too. The important part is that wood doesn't move equally in every direction.
Movement along the length of the grain is usually very small. Movement across the grain can be substantial. That means a 36-inch-wide solid hardwood tabletop may be noticeably wider during a humid Indiana summer than it is during a dry winter when the furnace has been running for months. You aren't going to stop that movement with screws. You may, however, stop your furniture from surviving it.
The Problem Isn't Wood Movement
Beginning woodworkers sometimes think expansion and contraction mean something has gone wrong with the lumber. It hasn't. Wood movement isn't a defect. Building something that doesn't allow for it is.
Imagine fastening a wide solid wood tabletop rigidly to a base. The base doesn't want the top to change width, but the top does. Something eventually has to give. The tabletop may cup. A joint may separate. A screw can loosen or pull out. In the worst case, that beautiful top you've spent hours building can split. Fortunately, woodworkers have been solving this problem for centuries.
Solution #1: Give Your Screws Somewhere to Go
One of the simplest solutions is an elongated, or oblong, screw hole. Instead of drilling a round hole that locks the screw into one exact position, elongate the hole in the direction the wood needs to move. The screw still holds the tabletop securely against the base, but as the top expands and contracts, the screw can shift slightly within the elongated hole. The key is understanding which direction the wood needs to move. A slot running in the wrong direction is just a more complicated round hole. And don't tighten the screw so aggressively that you've
Solution #2: Sliding Dovetails
A sliding dovetail is an elegant way to mechanically connect two pieces while controlling their relationship to one another. Used correctly, a sliding dovetail can help keep a wide panel flat while still accommodating seasonal movement. Depending on the design, portions can be glued while other areas are left free to move. But this is where understanding the principle becomes more important than simply knowing the technique. A beautifully fitted sliding dovetail that prevents the wood from moving can create exactly the problem you were trying to solve. Fancy joinery doesn't overrule physics.
Solution #3: Breadboard Ends
Breadboard ends are another traditional solution you'll see on tabletops, desks, workbenches and other wide solid wood panels. A board is attached across the end grain of the larger panel, typically using a tongue-and-groove or mortise-and-tenon arrangement. The breadboard helps keep the panel aligned and provides a finished edge.
But there's an important detail. The center can be secured while the remainder of the joint must accommodate movement of the main panel. That also means the ends may not remain perfectly flush throughout the year. In one season, the main panel might extend slightly beyond the breadboard. In another, the breadboard might extend beyond the panel. That's not necessarily bad craftsmanship. It can be evidence that the joint is doing exactly what it was designed to do.
Build for the Wood You Have
How much movement should you expect? That depends on the wood species, how the lumber was sawn, the width of the board or panel, and the change in moisture content it experiences.
A narrow piece may move so little that you barely notice it. A wide solid wood dining table is another matter entirely. That's why experienced woodworkers don't simply ask:
"How do I attach this tabletop?"
They ask:
"How do I attach this tabletop securely while still allowing the wood to move?"
That one additional question can determine whether a piece of furniture lasts five years or becomes something your grandchildren fight over.
Work With Wood, Not Against It
One of the pleasures of woodworking is that wood isn't a perfectly uniform manufactured material. Every board is different. Grain changes. Color changes. Knots appear where you weren't expecting them. And the wood moves. Learning to anticipate those characteristics rather than fight them is part of becoming a better woodworker.
At Crossroads Fine Woodworking, that's the kind of knowledge we want people to gain along with learning how to operate a table saw, router, jointer or planer. Understanding why something is done is ultimately more valuable than simply memorizing how to do it. So the next time you're attaching a beautiful solid wood tabletop, remember:
Wood doesn't care how tightly you installed the screw.
It's going to move anyway.
Your job is to give it somewhere to go.
-Andy